When churches conduct a pastor finder search, they often make many mistakes as they try to find the perfect preacher for their congregation. I have seen churches that go for a year or longer without a senior pastor, and this can really damage a church congregation. Church committees are great for electing new pastors for a congregation, but they can also needlessly prolong the process of selecting a new minister.
These are the five mistakes many churches make when searching for a new minister.
1. They don’t groom the current youth pastor for the senior pastor position.
Churches often hire youth pastors to lead the youth ministry, but they don’t think about the future of the church. The average tenure of a youth pastor is less than two years, so it is easy to understand why most churches don’t hire a youth minister with the future in mind.
George Barna, the leading expert on Christian statistics, has stated that the average tenure of a senior pastor is only four years. When the church hires a new youth pastor, it is reasonable to assume that the youth pastor could be promoted to the senior pastor position. Even though this is an uncomfortable conversation, you should consider asking the senior pastor if he feels he will be in his position for a long time. If the senior pastor is near retirement age or might leave in a few years, then the youth pastor should be hired with the possibility that they could succeed the senior pastor.
2. They take too long to find a pastor.
This is very common in many churches. Once you know that a pastor is leaving, the search for a new minister should begin immediately. Don’t wait for the senior pastor to leave. The church should immediately form a committee to lead the search for the next senior pastor.
3. Churches assume the existing associate pastor or youth pastor is the next senior pastor.
It is very easy to assume that one of the existing pastors on staff should be the next senior pastor. While this is often what happens in larger congregations, the church should consider other candidates too. The existing pastors on staff should assume that other outside candidates may be considered for the senior pastor position.
It is also possible that the associate pastor or youth pastor is not interested in the senior pastor position. The search committee should clearly communicate to the existing pastors on staff that they should not feel obligated or forced into the senior pastor position. You want someone who is clearly called to the pulpit, and that person might be outside the congregation.
4. They don’t conduct a background check with the leading candidates.
Never assume that an outside candidate who has worked in churches forever automatically has a clean record! Complete a thorough background check before hiring a new minister.
5. They don’t advertise the position.
There are numerous job sites where you can post open positions. Some of these sites even specialize in jobs for Christians and jobs for churches. Any reasonable search for a new pastor should include a job posting where you allow other pastors looking for a congregation to apply for the vacant pastor position. When you post a position opening on a targeted website for pastors, it is not uncommon to have hundreds of applicants apply for the job.
These are just some of the pastor finder mistakes many churches make when looking for a new pastor. Above all else, the church needs to pray and seek the Lord’s will when looking for a new minister. If the congregation is truly praying and listening to God’s voice regarding the next senior pastor of your church, then you will be able to come to an agreement on the right person to lead the church body.